s3xmoditmania V: ROUND 5: THE FINALE
BotB Academy Bulletins
Level 27 Chipist
post #89026 :: 2017.08.10 6:17pm :: edit 2017.08.17 4:12pm
  MiDoRi, Jimmyoshi and stinkbug liēkd this

ROUND 4 RESULTS: https://s3m.it/compo/809

PACK HERE: https://goo.gl/Kxy2YS

JOIN HERE: https://s3m.it/



You had the highest overall scores in round 4 and you have therefore advanced to the FINAL ROUND!

Deadline is THURSDAY AUGUST 17th at 16:00 PT / 23:00 UTC

do your best to win!!!! get that shiny (or not-so-shiny) trophy!!
Level 27 Chipist
post #89028 :: 2017.08.10 6:29pm :: edit 2017.08.10 6:42pm
  MiDoRi and Jimmyoshi liēkd this
a side thing! for anyone involved in any part of this compo: i have been debating whether to include the MPTM format as part of the compo next year. for the unaware, it's basically an openmpt-exclusive extension of the IT format with most of the same effects and features, but a few extras thrown in here and there.

i don't think it would really be an issue especially now that MPTM as a format is becoming a bit more mainstream, but i want your opinions!

(note: this WOULD NOT allow the use of the directx plugins)

whatever is in the lead by the deadline on tuesday will be the choice i go with next year
Level 27 Chipist
post #89029 :: 2017.08.10 6:36pm
  charlotte, Jimmyoshi and Sinc-X liēkd this
i swear i clicked no but it says i voted yes and my actions are immutable
Level 25 Mixist
post #89033 :: 2017.08.10 11:31pm :: edit 2017.08.10 11:32pm
  Sinc-X liēkd this
i don't care if i'm eliminated i'm making a song with this pack anyway

thank goodness for summer chip
in b4 password-protected zips in future s3xmoditmanias
Level 21 Mixist
post #89034 :: 2017.08.10 11:57pm
  10ctagon2, Bitfox, Sinc-X and Jimmyoshi liēkd this
Yay, final round

i'm so tired, help
Level 17 Mixist
post #89039 :: 2017.08.11 4:21am
  stinkbug and Post-retro liēkd this
  MiDoRi and Jimmyoshi hæitd this
I don't think we should include mptm in the format because my computer runs linux and openmpt doesn't run on linux
Level 27 Chipist
post #89040 :: 2017.08.11 5:13am
  MiDoRi and Jimmyoshi liēkd this
  Jangler hæitd this
but openmpt should run fine in wine? and also by that logic it should be removed from botb as well???? ( and it's not like you would have to use mptm if it were included lol)
Level 27 Chipist
post #89041 :: 2017.08.11 6:13am
  Post-retro, VinCMG and Sinc-X liēkd this
you'd have to use openmpt for playback and voting, though. afaik openmpt is well-supported by wine (or vice-versa) so practically speaking that is not much of an issue.

it'd just suck for people who use anything other than openmpt to write modules (since they're no longer on a level playing field) or play back modules (since they'd have to install new software for it). it's the sort of thing that could tip the scales for people like me who are borderline on voting/not voting. everyone and sincx's brother uses openmpt though so maybe that's a small sacrifice to make.

the botb analogy is lame which is why i hætid your comment sorry
Level 27 Chipist
post #89042 :: 2017.08.11 6:27am
well the playing field is already unbalanced by allowing .mod and .it in the same compo, or even .xm and .it, so i don't think it would make much difference in that regard.

for voting, if some are deadset against openmpt then i don't mind compiling mp3s for that small subset of people if this were to go through.
Level 27 Pixelist
post #89058 :: 2017.08.11 4:39pm
  stinkbug liēkd this
due to the builtin effects mptm is closer to allgear or xrns than to xm/it IMO, which makes it more unfair than .xm vs .it. but raising the sound design/production ceiling is also very tempting (and i'm pretty sick of setting up samples/insts for "xaimus reverb")
Level 23 Mixist
post #89059 :: 2017.08.11 4:39pm
  Sinc-X liēkd this
this round is going to be twisted
Level 21 Mixist
post #89063 :: 2017.08.11 6:00pm
  MiDoRi liēkd this
Openmpt is explicitly supported on linux with Wine, the only thing you don't get is the directx effects and some vsts might not work

Also there is a libopenmpt plugin for xmplay that allows you to play mptms in it, but yeah i agree mptm is a little too exclusive, and a little too powerful unless you basically restrict it to "IT but with hipass, S9F, \xx, and oxx
Level 16 Pixelist
post #89071 :: 2017.08.12 4:57am
  Post-retro and 10ctagon2 liēkd this
I don't know if my words are worth anything, since I sadly had no time to commit myself into this compo, but I think adding mptm would ruin the spirit of the whole thing, as everyone would use that format and it would turn out as a mptm compo. And this would penalize the few xm users!
Level 28 Chipist
post #89077 :: 2017.08.12 8:12am
  stinkbug, Bitfox and 10ctagon2 liēkd this
@galak sea
bitfox says otherwise
Level 26 Chipist
post #89079 :: 2017.08.12 8:41am
  Post-retro liēkd this
I voted no because I would have no proper way of playing them back (and I am not interested in getting Windows emulation for this purpose). Thus, I cite a platform incompatibility for this reason.
Level 27 Chipist
post #89084 :: 2017.08.12 11:25am :: edit 2017.08.12 11:29am
  Bitfox, 10ctagon2, Jimmyoshi and VinCMG liēkd this
quick reminder that if you are a non-finalist making a troll song (which is perfectly allowed) to please make it clear that your song is a troll song!! (this has not happened yet. but just to be certain)

also if ur going to submit more than one song for one reason or another, PLEASE USE DIFFERENT NAMES otherwise it creates an issue with voting. from now on i will remove any older entries under the same name and keep only the most recent one
Level 27 Chipist
post #89191 :: 2017.08.14 10:09pm :: edit 2017.08.14 10:39pm
  10ctagon2 and Jimmyoshi liēkd this
  stinkbug hæitd this

i have an Important Announcement:

you now have until THURSDAY to do your final round entry because, I Feel Like It. and you all deserve it.

if you have already submitted, feel free to take this time to make your entry even better! (or don't)

the vote period will also be an extra day so the final results if all goes to plan should happen on sunday

(sorry pug :( x)
Level 27 Mixist
post #89192 :: 2017.08.14 10:10pm
  10ctagon2 and Sinc-X liēkd this
I love you.
Level 27 Chipist
post #89196 :: 2017.08.14 10:47pm
  funute and MiDoRi liēkd this
this is pedantic but wine is a compatibility layer and not an emulator
Level 13 Mixist
post #89201 :: 2017.08.15 1:10am
  Sinc-X, stinkbug and Jangler liēkd this
  MiDoRi hæitd this
wine stands for Wine Is aN Emulator
Level 25 Chipist
post #89204 :: 2017.08.15 3:50am
  Jimmyoshi liēkd this
i thought i was supposed to drink it
Level 20 Pixelist
post #89207 :: 2017.08.15 5:39am
  funute, VinCMG and Jangler liēkd this
Minerscale, even if you don't want to install Wine, MPTMs can be played natively on Linux, since there are OpenMPT123 binaries
available for several distributions. It's a pretty convenient CLI player, just grab it and you're ready to go voting, even if you're not planning to enter the compo with MPTM song yourself. There's also a plugin for Audacious
, just not in precompiled form.
Level 22 Mixist
post #89214 :: 2017.08.15 1:27pm
  Sinc-X liēkd this
my suicide was in vain i see. fool that i am
Level 27 Mixist
post #89215 :: 2017.08.15 1:42pm
  10ctagon2 liēkd this
I do not recommend attempting to drink software
Level 21 Mixist
post #89216 :: 2017.08.15 1:57pm :: edit 2017.08.15 2:00pm
  MiDoRi and Sinc-X liēkd this
Ok so what happened is i was fucking about trying to clean up some folders, mistyped an rm command and ended up nuking my s3xmodit folder by accident last night, and my last backup was before r5 started

I wasn't very happy with my entry so I'd already kinda prepared to drop out and i was really not expecting the extension to happen....... I'm super sorry
Level 8 Mixist
post #89276 :: 2017.08.17 7:10am
when is the stream starting
Level 27 Chipist
post #89309 :: 2017.08.17 4:12pm :: edit 2017.08.17 4:49pm
  10ctagon2, VinCMG and Jimmyoshi liēkd this
votepack: https://s3m.it/pack/812

vote link: https://goo.gl/forms/FkxM6F9bbZv2fMFu2

Fill in the form as instructed. This will determine the winner! Good luck to all!

http://media.smwcentral.net/Sinc-X/svx/r5mp3.zip mp3s for anyone that needs them :) rendered with requested interpolation if applicable, otherwise with cubic. manis5 has bonus subsongs that are not included in the mp3 render, so you'll still have to use the module if you want those
Level 27 Chipist
post #89317 :: 2017.08.17 10:07pm
  10ctagon2 liēkd this
10ctagon2 if you're not going to follow the rules your votes won't be counted. your own song goes last, whether it's a legitimate entry or not. no buts.
Level 8 Mixist
post #89318 :: 2017.08.17 11:10pm :: edit 2017.08.17 11:21pm
  VinCMG hæitd this
@Sinc-X Done.

also to note:

This is a very serious entry song about something else I wasn't proud with leaving out in the darkness.

Not the mention the "Inspired melody" sample.
Level 27 Chipist
post #89320 :: 2017.08.17 11:58pm
  10ctagon2 liēkd this
you still voted yourself 4th
Level 25 Mixist
post #89321 :: 2017.08.18 1:09am :: edit 2017.08.18 1:09am
  VinCMG and Bitfox liēkd this
(wakes up from slumber)




it's friday

guess i'll make a digest video or something later i guess

(goes back to slumber)
Level 8 Mixist
post #89323 :: 2017.08.18 3:31am :: edit 2017.08.18 3:32am
  VinCMG hæitd this
Fine, then everyone can vote.

I had to listen a bunch of good songs and they go first.

LOGIN or REGISTER to add your own comments!